Skip to content
Navo24Navo24
White semi-truck pulling a yellow trailer past a freight train on Airline Highway

LTL vs FTL Shipping: What the Yellow Shutdown Showed Shippers

Photo: Infrogmation, CC BY-SA 4.0

LTL vs FTL shipping comes down to pallet count and, less obviously, to terminals you do not own. Less than truckload (LTL) means other shippers’ cargo rides in your trailer and the freight usually passes through the carrier’s terminals. Full truckload (FTL) means you hire the trailer for yourself. In July 2023 one of the largest LTL carriers in the United States stopped taking freight within days, and the way it stopped shows what the first option costs when the network disappears.

What the Yellow shutdown did to a network shipper

Yellow was a Nashville carrier with about 30,000 employees (Fortune). The collapse took days. On July 17, 2023, the day the Teamsters threatened to strike, Yellow was moving about 40,000 shipments, already some 20% under its 2022 average. The numbers come from a filing by its restructuring chief, reported by FleetOwner. By Friday the count was near zero, after roughly 30,000, 20,000 and 10,000 on the three days before. Yellow’s own explanation, in its bankruptcy FAQ, is that customers needed to ensure their freight could be serviced without interruption, so volumes fell, though the FAQ blames the strike threat for that. On July 24 Yellow stopped accepting shipments. On August 6 it filed Chapter 11 in Delaware, putting the job losses at 30,000.

A pallet in a hub-and-spoke network depends on pickup, a local terminal, sorting, consolidation and, per Freightquote, possibly several terminals before the consignee sees it. Yellow owned 169 service centers with about 10,000 doors and leased 140 more with some 9,100. A shipper with freight in that network had a carrier and a sorting system at stake, and the freight was near zero by Friday, July 21, so the window to rebook was shorter than the week between the strike threat and the stop.

A full truckload skips the sort. Freightquote says shipments typically travel on one truck to one destination, so delivery time estimates are often more accurate, and with less handling at multiple stops the chance of damage also decreases.

Where the freight went, and what it cost

Experts quoted in an AP story on Fortune warned that former Yellow shippers may face higher prices at FedEx or ABF Freight, since Yellow had historically offered the cheapest price points in the industry. The terminals went next. In December 2023 the first round of a bankruptcy auction sold Yellow’s terminals for $1.88 billion, 128 owned and two leased properties spread over 21 winning bidders, by Trucking Dive’s count. XPO spent $870 million on 26 owned and two leased terminals. Estes paid $248.7 million for 24. Saia paid $235.7 million for 17. Knight-Swift got 13 for just over $51 million.

Pacific Global’s post-Yellow review puts the share freed up by the shutdown at roughly 8% of the market, while Elevenflo, an AI-assisted trade summary that cites TT News, gives 10 to 15%. The two figures do not agree, so treat the size of the gap Yellow left as uncertain. Pacific Global adds that Yellow’s mix leaned toward retail customers and lighter weights, in contrast with denser, industrial loads.

Pacific Global wrote that a demand recovery would help fill the terminals the buyers acquired. Pricing today tells a different story. The fourth-quarter 2026 TD Cowen/AFS Freight Index projects LTL rate per pound at 82.5% above its January 2018 baseline, up 8.8% year over year, the first quarterly reading on record above 80%. Demand stayed soft, AFS’s LTL pricing lead said, yet pricing stayed exceptionally strong, because of fuel and because carriers prioritize only profitable loads that fit their networks.

Truckload is climbing faster. The same index has its rate per mile 19.7% above the January 2018 baseline in Q3 2026 and 23.4% projected for Q4, a 14.7% rise on the year against 8.8% for LTL. In September 2026 Cass recorded a Truckload Linehaul Index of 154.8, 10.1% above a year before. With both modes up, last year’s rate sheet will not tell you which one wins on a lane today.

Size thresholds and freight class

Where does LTL end? Freightquote puts LTL between 150 and 15,000 pounds. Above that, or past 10 standard pallets, it calls truckload the best choice. FreightCenter sells something in between, partial truckload: freight too big for a typical LTL shipment but short of a whole trailer, possibly with fewer handling points than LTL. Neither threshold is law, and Freightquote itself calls LTL “ideal” there, not a limit. FreightCenter adds that a trailer does not have to be full: you can still book full truckload for dedicated space, less handling, faster transit or specialized equipment.

A load near the line deserves a partial truckload quote too, and the three should be compared on what they cost with accessorials.

Whatever the mode, the truck has to stay legal. The Interstate gross vehicle weight cap is 80,000 pounds under federal rules unless the Bridge Formula sets a lower figure, and some states allow more through grandfather rights. Navo’s load planner flags axle and floor-strength limits as you build a container or trailer plan.

Freight class often drives LTL rates. A commodity gets a number between 50 and 500 in the National Motor Freight Classification, from its density, handling, stowability and liability, and the denser and easier the freight, the lower the number and the bill. A wrong class, NMFTA warns, may mean reclassification charges, delays or damage. So the pallet gets weighed and measured, not estimated. FreightCenter describes class as generally not the primary pricing method for full truckload, which it prices on shipping distance, trailer type, carrier capacity and the shipment’s weight.

LTL vs FTL shipping: which conditions point to which mode

Freightquote lists its own triggers. It points to LTL if the freight is 150 to 15,000 pounds, goes to a residential address or a site that needs a liftgate, or has no urgent deadline. It points to FTL if time is tight, the volume is beyond LTL, or the load needs temperature-controlled or flatbed equipment.

FreightCenter also defaults refrigerated freight to full truckload, because it is time-sensitive. Refrigerated LTL does exist: FleetOwner publishes a routing guide of reefer LTL carriers by state pair, and says to contact carriers directly to confirm service. And both sites describe the LTL bargain the same way: it is often cheaper for smaller shipments, since you pay for your share of the trailer, in exchange for more transfer points and terminal stops that can lengthen transit.

Put your own shipment against these lists, remembering that they are default advice from two sellers. A shipment that trips triggers on both lists deserves two real quotes before you book.

What to keep on file before the next shutdown

The cheap moment to set up a second LTL carrier is while the first one still picks up your freight. Yellow’s customers got a week between the strike threat and the stop, and volume was near zero by day five. For each lane, name a backup. It needs an open account, a current rate sheet and one name in dispatch. Ask it for a live quote every quarter, so you have tested it before you need it.

Frequently asked questions

What weight limits apply to a truck on the Interstate?

The FHWA lists 80,000 pounds gross vehicle weight on the Interstate System, 20,000 pounds on a single axle and 34,000 on a tandem axle group spaced more than 40 and not more than 96 inches apart. The Bridge Formula can set a lower weight, and some states allow more through grandfather rights.

Is FTL faster than LTL?

FreightCenter says FTL is generally faster because the shipment typically travels more directly from pickup to delivery, while LTL freight may move through terminals and make additional stops along the route.

Does LTL freight need different packaging?

Freightquote advises consolidating goods into large, crated or palletized packages and packaging them so they stand up to handling during transfer to multiple trailers.

Built by people who move boxes for a living.

Tracking, schedules and load planning, as components you can adopt one at a time.

Track a container

Container, B/L or booking number. 240+ carriers, live status and ETA.