One infected worker at a Ningbo terminal in August 2021 was followed within a week by 50 container ships waiting at anchor, by a forwarder’s count. That episode shows the COVID impact on the shipping industry better than the annual totals, which look mild: maritime trade shrank by 3.8 per cent in 2020, and containers lost only 1.1 per cent, UNCTAD reported in its Review of Maritime Transport 2021. The pain landed on crews, ports and freight rates, and it raised a question about cargo insurance.
Volumes came back faster than equipment and port capacity
Oil, refined products and gas shipments fell hardest: together they lost 7.7 per cent in 2020, against 1.5 per cent for dry bulk. Container port throughput fell by a similar amount to container trade and totalled 815.6 million TEU. By the third quarter, boxes and dry bulk were moving at their earlier volumes, though UNCTAD says tanker shipping had yet to recover fully.
The rebound then ran into pandemic restrictions on logistics work. UNCTAD links them to shortages of equipment and containers, less reliable services, congested ports and longer dwell times. Carriers generally managed to mitigate the shock and disruption. Port and landside operations found it more difficult to adjust, and for shipping lines soaring freight rates, surcharges and fees bolstered profitability.
Crew changes stalled
As of the IMO’s September 2020 count, about 400,000 seafarers were stuck aboard, unable to be relieved, and as many again could not join a ship. Some crews had gone 17 months without a break. The Maritime Labour Convention sets an 11-month limit. IMO Secretary-General Kitack Lim warned that fatigued, mentally exhausted crews were still being asked to operate ships. In its 2021 review UNCTAD cited an International Chamber of Shipping estimate of around 250,000 still stranded.
One positive test closed a Ningbo terminal
On 11 August 2021 one COVID-19 case among the workforce stopped all operations at the Meishan terminal in Ningbo-Zhoushan. CNBC called the terminal key for cargo to Europe and North America. The port as a whole had handled 28.72 million TEU in 2020.
By the sixth day, 50 container ships sat at anchor waiting for berths, according to the forwarder V. Alexander’s 17 August update. CMA CGM advised that it would omit one call. Cosco advised that two trans-Pacific vessels, Cosco Fortune and Cosco Africa, would call at the Daxie terminal instead. The port authority claimed output held at 90% of capacity as ships switched terminals, while carriers were omitting port calls at Ningbo. The terminal reopened on 25 August after two weeks shut, a port official told Reuters.
So the carrier advisories split: one line dropped a call, another moved ships to a different Ningbo terminal, Daxie. A sailing cancelled outright is a blank sailing, which is a separate case. If a box of yours was booked on a Ningbo call that week, check the unit’s status with container tracking before you plan around a date.
Freight rates and surcharges climbed
Freight rates began to climb in the second half of 2020, with surcharges and fees rising alongside. UNCTAD says they increased further after the March 2021 closure of the Suez Canal, when the 20,150-TEU Ever Given grounded.
Routing around the Cape of Good Hope was an option, though IHS Markit said on 26 March that few ships would detour at that point. Its estimate for the detour was more than 3,000 nautical miles and another week on the Asia to Europe transit. UNCTAD separately notes that some voyages that did reroute added up to 7,000 miles.
UNCTAD expected small shippers to have it harder. It says they may be less able to absorb the extra cost, are at a disadvantage in rate and space negotiations, and may find it difficult to secure service contracts. UNCTAD’s simulation took the observed 243 per cent rise in the China Containerized Freight Composite Index between August 2020 and August 2021 as its input. The result in the UNCTAD review, global consumer prices 1.5 per cent higher in 2023 than without the freight rate surge if August 2021 rates persisted and all other factors were held constant, was a 2021 projection, not an outcome.
The delay exclusion in cargo insurance
A terminal closure leaves a shipper asking who pays for the delay. The Institute Cargo Clauses (A) of 2009 cover all risks of loss of or damage to the cargo, except as excluded by Clauses 4, 5, 6 and 7. Clause 4.5 then excludes loss, damage or expense caused by delay, even though the delay be caused by a risk insured against, except expenses payable under Clause 2. The broker can say whether your own policy follows that text. Ask before the next closure, because the COVID impact on the shipping industry showed how fast a terminal can stop.
What the rates did next
The surge did not last. UNCTAD’s 2023 review says spot container rates hit record levels in early 2022 and fell through the second half of the year. The Shanghai Containerized Freight Index dropped by more than 80 per cent to 967 points in June 2023, from a January 2022 peak of 5,067 that was five times its January 2019 level. Carriers earned almost $300 billion in operating profit in 2022, by UNCTAD’s estimate.
Frequently asked questions
What did UNCTAD expect for freight rates in its 2021 review?
That they would remain high. Its 2021 review said demand was strong and there was growing uncertainty on the supply side, with concerns about the efficiency of transport systems and port operations, and it noted calls for governments to intervene and for regulators to apply closer oversight of unfair market practices.
Was Ningbo the only Chinese hub disrupted by COVID cases in 2021?
No. CNBC noted that in June 2021 infections had already disrupted shipping hubs in southern China, including the Shenzhen and Guangzhou ports, two months before the Meishan closure.
Is the Meishan terminal the same as the Meidong terminal in carrier notices?
Yes. A V. Alexander advisory of 17 August 2021 names it as the Ningbo Meidong Container Terminal, also known as the Meishan Island terminal.
