Why use a freight forwarder? A SeaRates post on the subject lists five answers: expertise, service, software, a network, certifications. A federal appeals court showed in 1997 what one of the services can cost. The case began with a forwarder, Exchange Transport International, and newsprint going from St. John, Canada, to Jedda, Saudi Arabia. The bill of lading showed a freight charge of $67,794.62. The court later noted a rate dispute: the carrier billed Omni at a different rate than the forwarder had quoted. Exchange invoiced the shipper, Omni Lines, for the freight, and Omni promptly paid. Exchange applied the money to its own debts. Then it closed. The carrier, National Shipping Company of Saudi Arabia, said it was never paid. It sued Omni for the same freight.
The job list is long and one item on it is money
The Federal Maritime Commission defines freight forwarding services in 46 CFR 515.2. The definition is short. It covers dispatching of shipments on behalf of others to facilitate shipment by a common carrier. The list gives thirteen examples. It says it is not limited to them. Examples: ordering cargo to port, preparing export documents, booking space, preparing bills of lading, arranging warehouse storage and cargo insurance, coordinating movement from origin to vessel, advising exporters on letters of credit. Item eleven is odd. It reads “handling freight or other monies advanced by shippers, or remitting or advancing freight or other monies or credit in connection with the dispatching of shipments.” Most of the list is paperwork or logistics, and this line is cash.
Imports come with a deadline. For cargo arriving in the United States by vessel, the importer or its authorized agent files the Importer Security Filing in English. For most cargo, the seller, buyer, manufacturer, country of origin and commodity code are due no later than 24 hours before loading at the foreign port. The ship has not sailed yet, and once it has, container tracking shows where the box is. CBP is plain about it. It says that failing to comply could ultimately bring monetary penalties, more inspections and delay of cargo.
In 1997 the court presumed the shipper pays
The bill of lading in the Omni case was marked “Freight Prepaid”. The carrier said it had not been paid. Omni did not dispute that. The district court sided with Omni. On 6 March 1997 the Eleventh Circuit reversed. Its judges were frank about the discomfort: “any result we reach in this case necessarily will be somewhat inequitable.” Either Omni paid twice or the carrier went unpaid.
The court took the rule of an earlier Fifth Circuit case, Strachan Shipping v. Dresser. The shipper is liable unless the carrier released it. It quoted that court’s reasoning that a forwarder “has few assets, and he books amounts of cargo far exceeding his net worth,” so carriers must expect payment to come from the shipper even when it passes through the forwarder’s hands.
Then came the advice. “Should the shipper wish to avoid liability for double payment, it must take precaution to deal with a reputable freight forwarder or contract with the carrier to secure its release.”
The case went back to the trial court. The release question stayed open. “Freight prepaid” appeared to point toward release, and so did the carrier’s first attempts to collect from Exchange. The bill of lading cut the other way. It also entitled the carrier to all freight and charges “whether actually paid or not.” The opinion does not report the ending. The opinion also lists district courts that read “freight prepaid” as credit given to the forwarder, so in 1997 the rule was not uniform. Courts disagreed.
A $50,000 figure sits beside a $67,794.62 freight charge
In the United States a person acting as an ocean freight forwarder needs a license from the Commission. The same person must furnish evidence of financial responsibility, set by 46 CFR 515.21 at $50,000 for a forwarder and $75,000 for an NVOCC. The freight charge in the Omni case was larger than the $50,000 a forwarder must show today, though the two figures come from different decades. The opinion is silent on Exchange’s license. It is also silent on a bond. This is a scale check only.
So why use a freight forwarder? For the services above, with eyes open on the one that handles your money. Before paying a forwarder’s invoice for ocean freight, ask the carrier to confirm in writing whether your freight is paid or whether it looks to the forwarder alone. This is practical advice. It is not a court rule. The court named two precautions: deal with a reputable forwarder, or contract with the carrier for a release. The license and the bond are worth checking as well, and how to find a good freight forwarder walks through the FMC record.
Frequently asked questions
How long must an agent keep the power of attorney for an Importer Security Filing?
Under 19 CFR 149.5(c) an authorized agent keeps powers of attorney in English until revoked. Revoked powers of attorney and letters of revocation stay on file for five years after revocation, and CBP can ask to see them.
Who may send the Importer Security Filing together with the entry in a single transmission?
Under 19 CFR 149.5 only an importer acting on its own behalf or a licensed customs broker.
What if an importer has no bond for the Importer Security Filing?
The agent submitting the filing on the importer's behalf may post the agent's own bond. The importer must otherwise hold one of the bonds listed in 19 CFR 149.5, such as a basic importation and entry bond or an importer security filing bond.
